If you have federal student loans, you need to know the truth about Income-Driven Repayment Plans. Although these plans get promoted as a super-package that boosts your budget today and forgives your loans tomorrow, they can actually keep you in debt decades longer than necessary—and the dream of forgiveness rarely happens! That’s what we call a bad plan.
What Are Income-Driven Repayment Plans?
Income-Driven Repayment Plans (IDR) cover four kinds of plans offered by the Department of Education to help federal student loan borrowers manage their payments. That means this program isn’t available for use with private student loans.
Another disqualifier? Having defaulted loans. Those are ineligible for any IDR plans—but you can use student loan rehabilitation or consolidation to get back on track.1
Even though the four types of IDR have a few wrinkles of difference that we’ll walk you through, they all have two big things in common:
- Lower payments. Instead of making monthly payments based on the amount of your debt, IDR payments are determined by your income—usually from 10% to 15% of your discretionary income, depending on the date you took out the loan and other factors.
- Longer terms. Instead of working the standard 10-year term of payoff, IDR plans typically run for 20 or 25 years. The longer term makes sense mathematically: Smaller payments and more accruing interest add up to long-lasting debt. But it makes zero sense if your goal is to get out of debt and build wealth.
There is also a theoretical promise to forgive any remaining balance at the end of the 20- or 25-year term—but this rarely works out and it has a lot of conditions around it, as you’ll see.
Get a new student loan rate from a Ramsey-trusted company in 10 minutes.
The reasoning behind IDRs is simple but flawed: borrowers with really big balances compared to their income probably need help managing their student loan payments. And many people can relate! But if you know that feeling, keep in mind that both debt size and income can—and should—change over time, for the better.
As your income rises, your debt should steadily disappear. IDRs tend to do the opposite. They lock people into a pattern of low income and zero progress on debt—or even debt that grows! That combo will only slow down your dreams of financial peace.
Types of Income-Driven Repayment Plans
Just so we’re clear: We do not recommend these plans as your best strategy to eliminate debt. We actually teach everyone to get as big a shovel—err paycheck—as possible and use the debt snowball method as the quickest and most powerful way to become debt-free. But it’s worth knowing how IDR plans work—and why you should avoid them.
The four types of IDRs are:
- Income-Based Repayment (IBR)
- Pay As You Earn (PAYE)
- Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE)
- Income-Contingent Repayment
Income-Based Repayment (IBR)
A lot of people confuse Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) with Income-Based Repayment (IBR). Remember that IDR is the general term for these plans, while IBR is a specific type.
So what’s IBR all about?IBR sets up your monthly student loan payments based on two factors: the date when you became a new borrower, and your discretionary income. Here’s how payments for the two groups of borrowers are calculated:
- If you were a new borrower on or after July 1, 2014, you’ll generally pay 10% of your discretionary income monthly—but if that works out to be more than the 10-year Standard Repayment Plan amount, you wouldn’t qualify for IBR.
- Or if you were a new borrower before July 1, 2014, you’ll be looking at a monthly payment of 15% of discretionary income, but again, only if that amount would actually lower your payment in comparison with the standard repayment amount.2
The repayment periods for loans placed in IBR also depend on the date the loan originated.
- If you were a new borrower on or after July 1, 2014, it’s a 20-year term.
- And if you got into this mess before July 1, 2014? It’s a 25-year term. Yikes!3
Pay As You Earn (PAYE)
Like most IBR plan payments, the PAYE plan monthly payments are going to be 10% of your discretionary income.4 Another similarity PAYE has with IBR is that you can only set this up if the monthly payment would actually be lower than a standard payment.
Here’s one more wrinkle with PAYE—to do this, you must meet the Department of Education’s “new borrower” requirement, defined as follows:
- You must have had no outstanding balance on a Direct Loan or Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) Program loan originated on or after Oct. 1, 2007, and
- You must have received a disbursement of a Direct Loan on or after Oct. 1, 2011.5
Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE)
The name probably gives you a hint that this is similar to PAYE, with a couple of differences. The main features of the REPAYE plan are:
- Any borrower with federal student loans can use this plan within the usual rules for discretionary income we mentioned before.
- The term of repayment on REPAYE is 20 years, so long as all the loans were used for undergraduate study.
- But the term of repayment will be 25 years if any of the loans were used for graduate study—which should be more than enough to convince you to skip that master’s program in poultry science.6
This is the only form of IDR available for Parent PLUS Loan borrowers. But keep in mind that if you’re the parent in this scenario and your child is the student, you are not eligible for any kind of IDR—at least not with a normal Parent PLUS.
The only way to use an ICR for your repayment is by first consolidating your PLUS loan into a Direct Consolidation Loan with any other student loans you have as the parent.
The monthly payment amount for an Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) plan is calculated differently than for any other kind of IDR. It will be whichever amount is the lesser of:
- 20% of your discretionary income, or
- What you would pay on a repayment plan with a fixed payment over the course of 12 years, adjusted according to your income.7
You can also look forward to a Silver Anniversary on this plan, because the term of repayment is 25 years.8
Income-Driven Student Loan Cancellation
If you’ve come this far, you’re probably wondering how the student loan forgiveness or cancellation works for IDR plans. For all four types of IDR, if you have any remaining balance at the end of the term, it will be forgiven. Sounds great! Except for the problems.
As we’ve seen, all of these plans are built around staying in debt for at least 20 years, and some run as long as 25! Can you imagine having student loan debt well into your 50s? Or if you’re a parent, that could mean a future that includes paying off student loans as a senior citizen!
That length of time should already be a red flag to you that this is a very expensive form of forgiveness! It’s like getting your hopes up that if you will just agree to live in a shack for a couple of decades, there will be a modest brick ranch waiting for you as a reward on the other side.
But actually, it’s worse than that. Why?
Because even if you make steady payments on the loans for years, there are all kinds of rules and potential legal changes you must keep up with in order to preserve your eligibility for the theoretical forgiveness. Let’s see what they are:
- You have to make sure your income always stays low enough that you qualify for the IDR plan—which means it can’t go above the level where your payment would be higher than 10% of monthly discretionary income. So a promotion at work would probably put the kibosh on a loan cancellation. Your goal is literally to keep your income low in the hopes of getting some unknown future amount of the debt forgiven. That’s pretty dumb.
- You must recertify your income and family size annually in order to stay qualified within the forgiveness rules. (In addition to a loss of income, welcoming a new baby to your family is another event that can “help” borrowers qualify for an IDR. 🙄) If you don’t recertify by the annual federal deadline every single year working an IDR, it could result in having any previous years of qualifying payments erased and the chance at forgiveness canceled.
- Missing recertification in REPAYE automatically kicks you out of the program into another plan that won’t be based on your income. In fact, it will speed your debt deadline way up—even if you’ve jumped through all the hoops for years. The Department of Education will now treat your loan as if it’s on a new 10-year repayment plan, or it will require full repayment by the original term of your REPAYE, whichever falls sooner. Look at it like a balloon lease on your student loan—it could explode at any time.
- And in all three other kinds of IDR, missing recertification even once also disqualifies you from making income-based payments. You will remain on your previous schedule though, it’ just that you will now owe standard monthly payments as determined by your original loan amount. At least the payment hike is only temporary—if you recertify later, you can be reinstated into PAYE, IBR or ICR even after missing a deadline.
- Here’s one more gotcha with missing the certification deadline even once on IBR, PAYE or REPAYE: Any unpaid interest will now be added to the principal of your loans, which will be subject to compound growth as well.9
All of these potential pitfalls start to make it look as if IDRs and their promise of a faraway forgiveness someday are really just a ticket to decades of debt.
If the publicly posted rules about how to achieve loan forgiveness aren’t enough to keep you far from IDRs, consider this: A March 2021 report from the National Consumer Law Center says that among the roughly 2 million borrowers in an IDR who have been making payments for 20 years or more, only 32 applicants ever received total cancellation.10
Yes. Let’s say it again so it sinks in: Only 32 out of the 2 million who have ever started an IDR have actually managed to get their debt balances forgiven. It’s all a mirage.
And guess what? We haven’t even talked about the true cost of IDRs.
The True Cost of Income-Driven Repayment Plans
On March 11, 2021, President Joe Biden signed into law a $1.9 trillion stimulus package that included a change to standing student loan law.11 Prior to the new legislation, anyone who managed to stay qualified for their full 20 or 25 years of scheduled payments in an IDR—reminder just 32 have ever done so—would also be subject to hefty taxes at the time of forgiveness.
Talk about forgiveness with strings attached.
Until that law passed, the federal “forgiveness” was literally a tax event from the perspective of the IRS. Even granting the far-fetched idea of receiving one of the rare loan cancellations, borrowers were subject to a tax bomb where they would go from owing some huge student loan balance one day, to having it forgiven the next—but also owing the IRS, all at once and immediately, some substantial percentage of the canceled balance.
Doesn’t seem very forgiving! This is yet another serious potential drawback for IDR plans.
Now don’t misunderstand—we love the fact that the new law would suspend such tax bombs for those rare birds who cross the forgiveness finish line. But the key word here is suspend. For now, student loan forgiveness is exempt from federal tax. But the relief measure is only temporary. It’s currently set to expire on Jan. 1, 2026.12 And as political winds blow, this miraculous tax break could vanish overnight.
We don’t know about you, but a new five-year window of time when forgiveness isn’t taxed isn’t nearly enough reason for us to sign up for an IDR. Tax laws come and go, but there’s no substitute for gazelle intensity and the power of taking control of your money—regardless of what’s happening in Washington.
Applying for Income-Driven Repayment Plans
Still not convinced that IDRs are bad news? OK, we’ll give you the lowdown on how to apply. But don’t say we didn’t warn you off of these scams.
The Department of Education has an application and approval process for any IDR. If you have federal student loans—remember private loans don’t qualify—you can request an IDR either through your lender or at StudentAid.gov .
As we’ve mentioned several times, getting an IDR is all about certifying your income to prove it’s low enough to qualify for the “benefit.” And the obligation to recertify continues every year until you pay the loan off or get it forgiven after 20 or 25 years. (Surely the debt snowball method is calling your name by now?)
Is an Income-Driven Repayment Plan Right for You?
How about no? Seriously. You are smarter than an IDR plan.
Instead of speeding up your debt payoff, they slow it way down. Instead of inspiring you to get gazelle intense to find new forms of income, they encourage you to keep your income low. And among the millions of people who have endured 20 or more years inside an IDR, only a measly 32 loan balances have ever been forgiven by the Department of Education!
We think a much better plan than an IDR is to work the Baby Steps and fit your student loans in where they belong in that sequence.
- Once you have your $1,000 starter emergency fund, you are going to get intensely focused on paying off all of your debts from smallest to largest, starting with the little one.
- Whether your student loan is your smallest debt or not, you’re going to get to it eventually. Keep going with minimum payments on the student loan until you’ve cleared all smaller debts—you’ll get a lot of momentum and motivation as you knock out a few small wins!
- Now that you’re working the student loan in the right order—and making sure to cover your Four Walls of food, utilities, shelter, transportation—you should throw everything you’ve got at the beast. And remember, you’re now rolling everything you were paying toward smaller debts into your student loan payment. It will be paid off in no time!
Want to know another couple of ways to turbocharge your race out of debt? Check out our Quick Read Destroy Your Student Loan Debt. Then see if student loan refinancing could be a good option for you—a better rate and a shorter term will definitely pay off in the long run!